Get healthy, or else!


I read this rather disturbing article in the Associated Press today, in which it is reported that “Manchester is hoping to fight fat with a reward system that works like a retail loyalty card. But instead of earning credit for opening their wallets, residents will be rewarded for keeping their feet on the treadmill and their fridge stocked with healthy food.”

Now, on the surface, this might seem like a good idea. Heck, I could stand to lose a few myself, and who wouldn’t want to be rewarded simply for doing the right thing? But if you look a little under the surface, this becomes troubling.

First and foremost, I have a problem with the government sticking their nose into my personal life, no matter how benevolent the motive may seem. It’s a short but steep slope from “We’ll reward you for being healthy” to “Get healthy, or else!” Right now, they’re offering the carrot, but who’s to say that once we accept this latest incarnation of Nanny government that the carrot won’t be replaced with a big and expensive stick. For example, what’s to stop the government from offering two tax tables, one for people who meet its definition of “healthy”, and those who don’t. As an overweight man who loves to smoke, I know which table I’d be paying under.

“Ah Ha!”, you say. “Smith, you big fat smoker you, you’re a drain on the health care system! Look at me: I’m a non-smoking vegetarian who runs five miles a day! You and those like you should be like me!”

To which I say: that’s the price you pay to live in a FREE COUNTRY. (Remember that phrase?) You have to put up with my bad habits and I have to put up with yours. Chances are, you are not entirely vice free yourself. And even if you are, I have news for you: unless you get hit by a bus, you too will grow old and become a drain on the health care system. It happens to almost all of us.  Your wonderful “healthy lifestyle” won’t save you in the end.

Those who believe in the Nanny government and who wish to control us realize that they cannot do so without uniting people against a common enemy. For Hitler, it was the Jews. For McCarthy it was the Communists. For Nanny government advocates, it is: Bad Health. These people feel they can enact all manner of government intrusion into people’s lives, as long as it is being done in the name of Good Health.  Good Health has become our new Golden Idol.

And for some of you who were nonplussed at my recent post about the 2008 election, know this: this is exactly why I have never voted Democrat. It is why I remain profoundly concerned about the Obama presidency. This sort of thing is far, far more likely to occur in the United States under a Democratic government.

Says Timothy Armstrong, coordinator of the World Health Organization’s global strategy on diet, and quoted in the same article, “I haven’t seen any evidence that it works, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try it…as public health officials we really don’t have the luxury of waiting to see what works and what doesn’t. We really do know that, in terms of curbing the obesity epidemic, all of society needs to play a role”.

It takes a village, right Timothy? And naturally, this is being funded by (who else?) the taxpayers.

Just so no one gets the wrong idea here, let me state flat out that I realize that this program is benign and well meant. And yes, I realize it’s happening in England, but our two countries are so closely linked culturally that it’s no stretch to imagine it happening here. Just look at what the Boston Public Health Commission is trying to get away with. People are getting fatter (probably because they’ve stopped smoking). But I become deeply troubled when the government starts using its leverage to try to force me to live a certain way, because I realize how quickly and easily the can change from benevolent cajoling to a direct order.  I believe that, deep down, the Nancy Pelosi’s of the world don’t really want to be agreed with, they want to be obeyed.  Once people allow themselves to buy into the idea that Nanny government is taking care of them, anything is possible. “Get healthy, or else!”.

Now where did I put those Cheesey Puffs?


7 Responses to “Get healthy, or else!”

  1. November 13, 2008 at 4:46 pm

    As another overweight smoker, I agree entirely. Health has gradually become a moral issue.

  2. November 13, 2008 at 8:34 pm

    Rage against the machine, Smitty, and save me a few cheesy puffs. 😉

  3. November 14, 2008 at 9:11 am

    I would agree wholeheartedly. No wait let me clarify. In my humble opinion government’s purpose is to ensure that it’s citizens have equal opportunity for success within the capitalist system and fill in the gaps in the few areas where a capitalist system would not be effective (regulation as an example to make sure the banks do not repeat the same mistakes as they recently did). This premise in my opinion would also include government ensuring that those who may be disadvantaged (without money) receive the same rights as those who are advantaged (with money). I am sure that you would not care quite as much Smith if you had a couple of billion dollars because you would just pay for your health care for yourself if it was not provided to you. So with your example I would agree that no one should be denied health care when they are most vulnerable regardless of what they ate or are eating/smoking (ie a person with heart disease or cancer)or whether they can actually afford it. As well I would suggest that people should not be discriminated against in any way regarding their immigration status, age, gender, sexual orientation or the colour of their skin as is often the case (yes in Canada too). Problem is I think I am beginning to sound a little Democratic rather than Republican at this point. Oh wait I am just one of those “Canadian Socialists”. The question is really what we as a society are willing to support with our tax dollars. For example what are the rights of the elderly in a capitalist society. They are often seen as a drain on the system because they do not usually make money any longer. I would argue that their worth is far greater than society gives credit. I say this because all we need to do is look at the level of funding we provide for our sick and elderly to evaluate the way society looks at these people. Oh and same sex marriage…..Ok likely getting too controversial now but you know what I mean. This is why Spaz keeps me from speaking about politics.

  4. November 14, 2008 at 5:54 pm

    I couldn’t agree with you more. I don’t smoke anymore but I don’t want the gov’t telling me I can’t. And If I want to eat a pound of trans fats I am going to. And if I don’t want to wear a seat belt I won’t. I do wear one but I don’t like being told by the gov’t that I have to.

  5. November 21, 2008 at 1:10 am

    not touching this one.
    {the ~g stands for Grinch, just so you know)

  6. May 31, 2017 at 2:58 pm

    Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?
    I mean, what you say is important and all. However just
    imagine if you added some great photos or videos to give your posts more, “pop”!

    Your content is excellent but with images and video clips,
    this blog could undeniably be one of the most beneficial in its field.
    Superb blog!

Leave a Reply to spasmicallyperfect Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

taking up a glowing cinder with the tongs and lighting with it the long cherry-wood pipe which was wont to replace his clay when he was in a disputatious rather than a meditative mood" ~ Dr. John H. Watson ************************
visitor stats
Click to see full version by whos.amung.us
Click here if you want to learn the truth about second hand smoke
A Boston University Physician exposes the fallacies of the anti-smoking movement.

My Guests

  • 227,070 visitors
Murder of Ravens' RSS feed

What they’re reading

Everything you want to know about the movies of today and yesterday. One of my favorite websites. If you love classical music, you have to visit this site.
November 2008
« Oct   Dec »

Thoughts from the Past

Creating Order from Chaos

%d bloggers like this: